“Sabre-toothed tigers were tigers.”
No. They were not tigers and were not close to any living cat; no one knows whether they had stripes. 'Sabre-toothed cat' is the better name.
“Sabre-toothed cats stabbed their prey like a knife.”
Scientists reject this: the teeth could break on bone and the jaw could not open wide enough. They probably held prey down and bit the neck; exactly how is still debated.
“The 'false cats' (nimravids) were the ancestors of today's cats, or true cats.”
No. They are a separate group with no direct link to today's cats. The shape of the middle-ear bone is different.
“All big cats roar and no big cat purrs, and all small cats purr and cannot roar.”
Only lion, tiger, leopard and jaguar roar. The snow leopard cannot roar, and clouded leopards neither purr nor roar. Whether big cats can purr is not settled.
“Everybody agrees how many cat species there are.”
The number has hovered around 40 since the 18th century, and it changes with the rulebook: 37 (2008), 40 wild plus the house cat, 41 (2017).
“Big cats are the big ones and small cats the small ones.”
The split follows kinship, not size. The cougar is a small cat that grows very large, and the cheetah's closest relative is the cougar.
“Any striped tabby cat in a forest is a wildcat.”
Many striped house cats look like wildcats. Of about 100 reports to ARK, 99 were house cats. Check the tail, the back stripe and the hind foot, and know that only DNA is certain.
“A wildcat is just a house cat that has gone wild.”
It is a separate wild species with a history of hundreds of thousands of years. Strays are house cats; a wildcat has never been owned and is very hard to tame.
“The wildcat has always been rare in the Netherlands, or never lived there.”
It lived here until at least Roman times and vanished in the first centuries AD (other sources say before or since the Middle Ages). It came back from the Eifel and Ardennes after 2002.
“All house cats today descend from Egyptian cats.”
Two groups gave genes: Near Eastern cats in the Neolithic and an Egyptian line later. In Europe most cats come from a wave of African cats about 2,000 years ago.
“Cats came to Europe with the first farmers.”
The old DNA reading said so, but a 2025 study of 70 ancient cats found that those early cats were European wildcats with some African wildcat ancestry.
“Chinese farmers had domestic cats 5,000 years ago.”
The cats at Quanhucun were leopard cats; their link with people seems to have been short-lived and did not lead to the house cat. The first confirmed domestic cat in China is from about 730 CE.
“Cats are fully domesticated, like dogs.”
Cats are semi-domesticated: they were never strongly bred, their genes changed little, and many keep their wild behaviour.
“Egyptians shaved their eyebrows when a cat died.”
This is a story told by the Greek writer Herodotus. The embalmed cats of Bubastis are real, but most were very young and probably raised for mummification.
“Cats chose to live with people, so people did nothing.”
Cats probably started it by following mice, but people made the cat welcome and carried it across seas; later, people bred it for looks. Researchers call it self-domestication, with help.
“The Egyptians saved cats from burning houses only out of love for pets.”
It is a story told by Herodotus. It is usually read together with the cult of Bastet, who protected homes. It is a report, not a verified event.
“Killing a cat was punished by death in Egypt.”
Herodotus says deliberately killing a sacred animal was punishable by death but does not name the cat. Diodorus tells of a Roman lynched for killing a cat (60 to 56 BCE). Modern historians dispute how strict the rule was.
“700,000 people came to the Bubastis festival.”
Herodotus gives this as the figure the locals gave; other summaries say 'several hundred thousand'. It is an ancient writer's report, not a count.
“Cambyses won the battle of Pelusium by putting cats in front of his army.”
Polyaenus told this in the 2nd century CE, about 600 years later. The conquest of 525 BCE is history; the cat trick is a story without independent confirmation.
“Egypt had two kinds of sacred cat: a big wild one and a small house cat.”
Morrison-Scott measured the Giza skulls and found no clear two-form split. Apart from three jungle cats the mummies look like one form, close to the African wildcat.
“The ancient Greeks and Romans kept many house cats.”
House cats were rare; weasels were more common pets. One writer, Engels, argues cats were more popular in Rome, a single and contested view.
“Muhammad cut off his sleeve rather than wake his cat Muezza.”
No verified hadith mentions a pet cat of Muhammad. A 2020 fatwa from Malaysia asks that the story be told only to explain that it is not authentic.
“Freyja's cat chariot proves the Vikings revered cats as sacred.”
The cat chariot is told in the 13th-century Prose Edda, long after the Viking Age. The real Viking Age evidence is practical: pest control, fur, and cats in graves.
“Freya's black cat became evil after Christianisation, which is why black cats are thought magical.”
There is no good evidence for this. Only one source says it, without citations.
“The maneki-neko was born at Gotokuji Temple.”
A legend says so, but no document backs it up.
“Empress Helena shipped hundreds of cats to Cyprus in 328 CE.”
It is a Byzantine legend about the monastery of Saint Nicholas of the Cats; it is impossible to know if shiploads of cats were sent.
“Modern Cyprus cats descend from the 9,500-year-old Cyprus cat.”
There is no evidence for it. Breeders repeat the claim without checking.
“The word 'cat' comes from the Egyptian 'quattah'.”
Only one source says so, and not a language expert. It is unverified.
“In the Middle Ages people killed cats in huge numbers, so rats spread the Black Death.”
There is no written or archaeological evidence for such a massacre; the story rests largely on one modern book. Plague was blamed on God's punishment, not on cats. Cats that eat infected rats can catch plague themselves.
“The pope ordered all cats to be killed in 1233 (Vox in Rama).”
Vox in Rama describes an alleged sect with a black cat-shaped statue and calls for a crusade against that sect; it does not order the killing of cats. It is the likely, not proven, origin of the link between black cats and witchcraft.
“Black cats have always been witches' cats.”
Early English witches had white, tabby and other cats. One source says black cats joined the witch picture only in Victorian times, another traces it to Vox in Rama, so the origin is uncertain.
“Witch hunts were a medieval thing.”
Witch trials were rare for most of the Middle Ages and became common in the 16th and 17th centuries; an estimated 50,000 to 200,000 people were executed. Pointy hats and brooms became standard around 1720.
“Ieper has thrown cats from its tower since 962, or since a cat cult in 3842 BC.”
The year 962 is doubtful, and 3842 BC is impossible because Ieper did not exist then. The oldest real traces are the city accounts of 1410 to 1420; the first certain record is from 21 March 1590.
“The Ieper cat throw was moved in 1475/1476 to Cat Wednesday.”
There is no reliable evidence for this. The first certain records show the throw was always on the Wednesday of the fair.
“The Ieper cat throw is an ancient pagan rite or was always about witches.”
No firm origin is known. Legends say witchcraft or too many cats in the cloth hall; the scholarly sources call it a mix of truth and fantasy.
“Ship's cats protected crews from plague because rats on ships carried the Black Death.”
Before the 1890s rats were not typically linked to disease on ships. A 2018 study questions the rat's role in the Black Death.
“Cats cause storms, a cat overboard curses a ship, and extra-toed cats are the best ship's cats.”
Sailors' beliefs. Cats do sense weather changes through sensitive ears and low air pressure, but there is no evidence for storm magic or for extra-toed cats being better ratters.
“Black cats are the hardest to adopt.”
Studies conflict: the RSPCA (2014) found 70% of abandoned cats were black, while an American shelter reports black cats are adopted more than other colours. Treat both as local results.